Major Article| Volume 49, ISSUE 3, P309-318, March 01, 2021

# A hybrid model integrating warm heat and ultraviolet germicidal irradiation might efficiently disinfect respirators and personal protective equipment

Published:July 27, 2020

## Highlights

• Coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) has taken a heavy toll on human life.
• Creating a hybrid model that efficiently sanitizes the mask and increases its reuse.
• The hybrid system can be used as standalone systems also.

### Background

The pandemic coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) has taken a heavy toll on human life and has upended the medical system in many countries. The disease has created a system wide worsening shortage of N95, medical masks, and other personal protective equipment (PPE) that is regularly used by healthcare personnel and emergency service providers for their protection.

### Aim

Considering the number of infected patients and the stressed supplies of PPE, reuse of PPE can serve as an efficient contingency plan. Multiple studies have investigated the effect of different decontamination methods.

### Methods

We chose the most user-friendly, easily scalable viral decontamination methods, including ultraviolet irradiation and heat treatment. In this paper, we investigated a unique approach to reuse the mask by creating a hybrid model that efficiently sanitizes the infected mask.

### Results

The advantages of the proposed hybrid model as compared to the respective single arms is its decontamination efficacy, operational speed, as well as the number of reuse cycles as verified by mathematical analysis and simulation. This model is mainly intended for medical PPE but can also be used for other domestic and personal sanitization during the COVID-19 pandemic. As per the situation, the hybrid system can be used as standalone systems also. This sanitization process is not only limited to the elimination of Severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 but can be extended to any other infectious agents. Thus, our results indicate that the proposed hybrid system is more effective, meets disinfection criterion and time saving for the reuse of respirators and PPE.

## Key Words

Coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) is a pandemic that has hit 217 countries and territories, with 3,759,967 confirmed cases and at least 259,474 deaths across the world as of May 8, 2020, according to the World Health Organization Situation Report-109. In December 2019, the first outbreak was reported in Wuhan City of China, followed by a rapid escalation of cases worldwide. COVID-19 is officially named as Severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) and characterized by severe infection of the respiratory system.
• Huang C
• Wang Y
• Li X
• et al.
Clinical features of patients infected with 2019 novel coronavirus in Wuhan, China.
In the last 2 decades, coronavirus outbreaks have become common and have affected global health. In 2002-03 SARS-CoV and again in 2011, the Middle East respiratory syndrome corona virus rattled the world.
• de Wit E
• van Doremalen N
• Falzarano D
• Munster VJ
SARS and MERS: recent insights into emerging coronaviruses.
Coronaviruses are positive-strand RNA viruses and can be categorized into 4 genera, alpha, beta, delta, and gamma. The alpha and beta coronaviruses are known to infect humans. SARS-CoV-2 is a positive sense (+) single-stranded enveloped RNA ([+] ssRNA) virus and belongs to the beta coronavirus genus with a zoonotic origin.
• Paules CI
• Marston HD
• Fauci AS
Coronavirus infections-more than just the common cold.
Current research suggests that bats are the viral reservoir, while pangolin may be the facilitating intermediate host causing the transmission to humans.

Singh Y, Gupta G, Satija S, Pabreja K, Chellappan DK, Dua K. COVID-19 transmission through host cell directed network of GPCR. Drug Dev Res.2020;81:647-649.

The vital clinical symptoms include fever, dry cough and fatigue, while a small percentage of patients also exhibit gastrointestinal infection-related symptoms.
• Wu F
• Zhao S
• Yu B
• et al.
A new coronavirus associated with human respiratory disease in China.
High transmission rate, asymptomatic carriers, lack of testing, complex pathogenesis, and unavailability of medicine or vaccine attributed to the high infection rate of SARS-CoV-2.
COVID-19 is a highly contagious disease, and dissemination of this virus is mainly through the transfer of virus-laden respiratory droplets. Once the virus gets deposited in the respiratory system of an uninfected person via droplets (>5-10 µm in diameter), aerosolized droplet nuclei (<5 µm in diameter) or by contact can lead to transmission.
• Liu J
• Liao X
• Qian S
• et al.
Community transmission of severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2, Shenzhen, China, 2020.
The virus upon replication gets transported to other organ systems like the kidney, intestine, liver, and heart.
• Wang Q
• Zhang Y
• Wu L
• et al.
Structural and functional basis of SARS-CoV-2 entry by using human ACE2.
The droplet transmission of infection happens when the patient with respiratory symptoms comes in close proximity (under 1 m distance) or through fomites in the vicinity of a patient. Aerosolized droplet nuclei in certain circumstances can remain suspended for a longer period and also can travel distances greater than 1 m
• Liu J
• Liao X
• Qian S
• et al.
Community transmission of severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2, Shenzhen, China, 2020.
,

Setti L, Passarini F, Gennaro GD, et al. Airborne transmission route of COVID-19: why 2 meters/6 feet of inter-personal distance could not be enough. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2020;17:2932.

,
• Ong SWX
• Tan YK
• Chia PY
• et al.
Air, surface environmental, and personal protective equipment contamination by severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) from a symptomatic patient.
(Fig 1A). The viral enters into the human cell by the interaction of the viral spike (S) glycoprotein with the human angiotensin-converting enzyme 2 receptor, followed by virus-human cell membrane fusion and subsequent internalization of the viral genome. The viral RNA induces the synthesis of more viral particles and eventually buds off from the infected cell to spread infection.
• Lukassen S
• Chua RL
• Trefzer T
• et al.
SARS‐CoV‐2 receptor ACE2 and TMPRSS2 are primarily expressed in bronchial transient secretory cells.
The infection cycle is explained in Figure 1A. Epidemiological investigation suggests a median incubation period of 5.1 days and 97.5% of patients who will develop symptoms exhibit those symptoms within 14 days of infection and are also associated with viral shedding in the latency period.
• Lauer SA
• Grantz KH
• Bi Q
• et al.
The incubation period of coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) from publicly reported confirmed cases: estimation and application.
Transmission control and personal protective equipment (PPE). The most effective mitigation plan is “social distancing,” isolation and self-quarantine and is practiced all over the world. As per the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), USA, social distancing refers to maintaining a 6 feet space between yourself and other people outside of your home. An essential strategy for protecting healthcare workers, sick patients and emergency responders on the frontline of fighting with Covid19 requires the use of PPE, especially in the form of a face mask known as N95 respirator or N95 filtering facepiece respirators.
• Azap A
• Erdinc FS
Medical mask or N95 respirator: when and how to use?.
,
• Wang X
• Pan Z
• Cheng Z
Association between 2019-nCoV transmission and N95 respirator use.
The grade of N95 respirator is regulated by the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health. It is meant to exhibit a minimum filtration efficiency of 95% for 0.3 µm (aerodynamic mass mean diameter) of sodium chloride aerosol.
• Liao L
• Xiao W
• Zhao M
• et al.
Can N95 respirators be reused after disinfection? How many times?.
The SARS-CoV-2 virus is pleomorphic in form and the size ranges from 60 to 150 nm as per different investigating groups, like 70-90 nm
• Kim JM
• Chung YS
• Jo HJ
• et al.
Identification of coronavirus isolated from a patient in Korea with COVID-19.
; ∼ 150 nm
• Matsuyama S
• Nao N
• Shirato K
• et al.
Enhanced isolation of SARS-CoV-2 by TMPRSS2-expressing cells.
; 60-140 nm
• Cascella M
• Rajnik M
• Cuomo A
• Dulebohn SC
• Di Napoli R
Features, Evaluation and Treatment Coronavirus (COVID-19).
; 80-120. Balazy et al, 2006 showed that the N95 respirator could provide >95% protection from particles with a diameter of 80 nm.
• Balazy A
• Toivola M
• Sivasubramani SK
• Reponen T
• Grinshpun SA
Do N95 respirators provide 95% protection level against airborne viruses, and how adequate are surgical masks?.
Therefore, the N95 mask can be highly effective in preventing airborne transmission in high-risk hospital conditions and CDC recommends its use for all healthcare professionals. However, there are some limitations to using a mask. Self-contamination may occur due to touching and reusing contaminated mask. Mainly in the health sector doctors are using a mask at random to treat infected patients and there is every chance of the mask getting infected. Therefore, after using any mask, it is essential to dispose of that mask or can be reused after disinfection. As per the CDC, surgical masks do not provide a reliable level of protection and are loose-fitting and disposable, but can protect from the exposure of large droplets, splashes or sprays of pathogenic fluids. N95 and the medical masks used in the healthcare setting is intended for 1-time use and not to be shared or reused.
• Azap A
• Erdinc FS
Medical mask or N95 respirator: when and how to use?.
Most countries have recommended the use of single-use face masks and homemade masks for the general public.
Components of an N95 mask. There is an acute shortage of PPE, especially the N95 respirators in many countries. Health workers are facing a real challenge, forcing them to disregard the basic infection control protocols while serving corona infected patients
• Nogee D
• Tomassoni AJ.
Covid-19 and the N95 respirator shortage: closing the gap.
. Considering the cost and limited supplies, 1 option is to decontaminate the respirators and then reuse it. A recent study investigated the viability of SARS-CoV-2 on different surfaces, including plastic, and the viable virus was observed up to 72 hours (103.7 to 100.6 of the 50% tissue culture infectious dose or TCID50/ ml of media)
• Van Doremalen N
• Bushmaker T
• Morris DH
• et al.
Aerosol and surface stability of SARS-CoV-2 as compared with SARS-CoV-1.
. Figure 1B shows the different component layers of a typical N95 mask. These layers are made of polypropylene nonwoven fabric. The most important layer (100-1000 µm) is then made by the melt-blown process in which melted polypropylene is extruded through a fine nozzle and combined with the heat-mediated self-adhesion leads to the formation of stacked, nonwoven microfibers (diameter ∼ 1-10 µm) as shown in Figure 1B.
• Lam T-N
• Wu C-H
• Huang S-H
• et al.
Multi-scale microstructure investigation for a PM2.5 air-filter efficiency study of non-woven polypropylene.
The microfibers are finally charged by the corona discharge method, creating the “electret” property that enhances the filtration efficacy of the mask. There are 2 options available, firstly, to dispose of the mask, which may not be a viable option due to its supply deficiency, cost-effectiveness, and biohazard disposal cost. The second option is reusing the mask after proper decontamination/sanitizing process.
Available methods for N95 mask sterilization. One sanitization option is to leave the contaminated mask for hours under the sun (direct heat) and wait for the virus on the surface of the mask to get inactivated. However, this method will be time-consuming and challenging on a large scale. Research suggests limited availability of decontaminating agents for SARS-CoV-2, including alcohol, soap solution, vaporous hydrogen peroxide (H2O2), moist heat and ultraviolet (UV) irradiation. Every method has its merits and demerits, but their effect on the SARS-CoV-2 viability needs to be strictly studied. The most common sanitizing agent ,that is, alcohol and soap, can effectively deactivate SARS-CoV-2 but significantly reduces the filtration efficacy of the N95 mask
• Heimbuch BK
• Kinney K
• Lumley AE
• Harnish DA
• Bergman M
• Wander JD
Cleaning of filtering facepiece respirators contaminated with mucin and Staphylococcus aureus.
(Table 1). H2O2 vapor (HPV) and gas plasma are used for medical N95 mask decontamination recently.

Kenney P, Chan BK, Kortright K, et al., Hydrogen peroxide vapour sterilization for N95 respirators for reuse [e-pub ahead of print]. medrxiv. https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.03.24.20041087. Accessed August 28, 2020.

The key drawbacks of the use of H2O2 include residues left out due to insufficient off-gas time, which can pose serious respiratory and skin hazards. H2O2 is a strong oxidant, presents a combustion and explosion risk, and therefore, a skilled workforce is required to handle the decontamination system. Improper producing and limited decontamination cycles make a tricky choice. In the absence of better methods US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has recently authorized some H2O2-based system. Electron-beam irradiation is costly and possess dangers to the user and hence not used.
Soap water78%21.9%
Alcohol62.9%37%
Sun (Direct heat)99%Time is a constraint ( approx 5 hours)
One of the common methods is warm moist heat (WMH), where the mask is subjected to a temperature of 65°C in a heat chamber.
• Heimbuch BK
• Wallace WH
• Kinney K
• et al.
A pandemic influenza preparedness study: use of energetic methods to decontaminate filtering facepiece respirators contaminated with H1N1 aerosols and droplets.
• Viscusi DJ
• Bergman MS
• Novak DA
• et al.
Impact of three biological decontamination methods on filtering facepiece respirator fit, odor, comfort, and donning ease.
• de Man P
• van Straten B
• van den Dobbelsteen J
• van der Eijk A
• Horeman T
• Koeleman H
Sterilization of disposable face masks by means of standardized dry and steam sterilization processes; an alternative in the fight against mask shortages due to COVID-19.
This affects the average log reduction of the viable virus without affecting the coating of the mask. Another method is microwave generated steam (MGS), where the contaminated mask can be loaded into a commercially available microwave oven with a small amount of water in a microwave approved pan to create steam. However, as most of the N95 and medical mask have metallic noseband so this process may not be useful. A very effective method is UV Germicidal Irradiation (UVGI), where 254 nm, UV-C lamp can be used.
• Lindsley WG
• Martin Jr., SB
• Thewlis RE
• et al.
Effects of ultraviolet germicidal irradiation (UVGI) on N95 respirator filtration performance and structural integrity.
The infected mask can be exposed to a UV radiation ≥1 J/cm2 for 15 minutes for viral inactivation. However, in some types of mask penetration reachability of UV in their inner layers suffers and shadowing can cause major concerns.
• Lindsley WG
• Martin Jr., SB
• Thewlis RE
• et al.
Effects of ultraviolet germicidal irradiation (UVGI) on N95 respirator filtration performance and structural integrity.
This is due to their design constraints, but this method does not harm the layering of the mask although the fitting elasticity can be hampered on repeated uses. Table 2 reflects the characteristics of all of these technical processes.
Table 2Comparison of the technical methods
MethodRequirementVirus average log reductionDemerits
WMHHeat chamber4.81Start-up time
MGSMicrowave oven5.06Not suitable for N95
HPVH2O2 vapour6Extra safety at the interior side
From the above Table 2, it is clear that all the methods have a certain advantage and reach an appreciable and acceptable level of virus level reduction. However, every process has its demerits also and it can be found that hazards in the case of WMH are least and in UVGI, it is quite less. Different disinfection methods including chemical, radiation and thermal treatment, have been recommended by CDC.

WA Rutala, DJ Weber. Disinfection and sterilization: an overview Am J Infect Control. 2013;41:S2–S5.

Though single agents are discussed and used by many but no hybrid systems have been tested. As a result of this, we propose a hybrid model to efficiently sanitize the compromised mask. The efficacy of this proposed model is its operational speed in achieving the high log decontamination, cheap, can be easily installed within a medical unit and ease of operation for people throughout the world.
Rationale and hypothesis. We concentrated on user-friendly, potentially scalable and time-saving decontamination methods for our study that will conserve the integrity, efficiency, and increase the number of reuse cycle of N95 and medical masks. The SARS-CoV viruses are constituted by different proteins, lipids and RNA as the genetic material and heat treatment is known to inactivate viral and bacterial pathogens.
• Rabenau HF
• Cinatl J
• Morgenstern B
• Bauer G
• Preiser W
• Doerr HW
Stability and inactivation of SARS coronavirus.
Heat treatment can denature proteins and affect lipid stability. Many researchers are currently trying to harness the power of UV radiation to disinfect SARS-CoV-2. Short wavelength UV also called UV-C, can inactivate the ARS-CoV at a fluence of ∼3.6 J/cm2.
• Darnell ME
• Subbarao K
• Feinstone SM
• Taylor DR
Inactivation of the coronavirus that induces severe acute respiratory syndrome, SARS-CoV.
Liao et al, 2020 used moist heat (85°C, 30% RH) disinfection method and showed that in N95 can be used for 50 cycles without significant alteration in filtration efficiency. They also reported that UV irradiation could be used for 10 cycles without any alteration and with slight degradation by the 20th cycle.
• Lindsley WG
• Martin Jr., SB
• Thewlis RE
• et al.
Effects of ultraviolet germicidal irradiation (UVGI) on N95 respirator filtration performance and structural integrity.
Heimbuch et al and Cadnum et al demonstrated decontamination methods like microwave-generated steam, low-temperature moist heat, and UV irradiation separately, provided >4-log reduction of viable H1N1 virus H5N1 influenza viruses without significantly affecting filtering facepiece respirators fit or function.
• Heimbuch BK
• Wallace WH
• Kinney K
• et al.
A pandemic influenza preparedness study: use of energetic methods to decontaminate filtering facepiece respirators contaminated with H1N1 aerosols and droplets.
As many UV-C is known to induce oxidation and RNA self-cleavage in single-stranded RNA viruses.
• Ariza-Mateos A
• Prieto-Vega S
• Diaz-Toledano R
• et al.
RNA self-cleavage activated by ultraviolet light-induced oxidation.
We hypothesized that heat can inactivate viral protein and lipids, and UV disintegrates the genomic material (RNA), and therefore, a combination of both can be more effective in neutralizing the SARS-CoV-2 virus.

## Methods

### Analysis of WUVH

Considering the model of WUVH as a single input and single-output system, we effectively use an approach where the outputs can be forecasted. Model predictive control
• Watkins NJ
• Nowzari C
• Pappas GJ
Robust economic model predictive control of continuous-time epidemic processes.
,
• Lee JH
Model predictive control: review of the three decades of development.
is used to forecast the system behavior. This is a feedback model and is used to predict the current values depending upon the difference between the actual and predicted values.x
The model is considered as a first-order time-delay model with transfer function
$Y(s)U(s)=Ke−φsτs+1$
(1)

Where K is the steady-state gain, τ is the time constant and φ the delay time. These are the crucial parameters in determining the correct prediction. A stable dynamic process can be commonly defined and described by the first-order time-delay model. This model is used to obtain the initial controller tuning constant, easy to compute and have robust control. Taking a higher-order model unnecessarily will increase the system complexity with marginally better control over the first-order model but will potentially undermine the robustness of the system. The corrected predictions are made with step input at time t = 2 minutes by considering a step disturbance in the range of d = 0.15-0.20. For better operation, this step disturbance should be kept in the range of 0.15. This is because an increase in step disturbance may result in enhanced output but at the cost of shifting the process from the setpoint value. The sampling period Δt is considered to be 1 min. Moreover, for prediction, the samples are considered over a time span of 0 < t ≤ 80. Because $φ=2minutes$ and the step u begins at t = 2 minutes, the output y(t) starts responding and the start-up time is at t = 5 minutes. So before that, the output will be zero for the first cycle. This is because the time required for a standard heater to boil water is around 4.6 minutes. This implies that the start-up time for the disinfection cycle to start. The step input disturbance due to predicting the output, due to the past output starts at t = 8 minutes. Thus, the output step response of the system with delay can be written as
$y(t)=0,fort≤4$
(2a)

$y(t)=5(1−e−(t−4)/15)for4≤t≤10$
(2b)

$y(t)=5(1−e−(t−4)/15)+5*0.15(1−e−(t−10)15)fort>10$
(2c)

The minimum infectious dose of SARS-CoV-2 is unknown so far, but researchers suspect it is low. Therefore, for purposes of analysis, we considered a >5 log 10 reduction of infectious agents on N95 respirators to be effective for the decontamination of respirators.

## Results

This section provides the results of our scheme and its comparison by conducting 3 sets of experiments along with a statistical plot. In each set of experiments comparison of WUVH is done with UVGISA and WUVH. The performance of the proposed WUVH is done using MATLAB, and 20 independent runs have been taken while plotting the graphs.

### Experimental analysis

In the first set of the experiment (Fig 3A), the output of the process in terms of achieving average log reduction after the treatment with respect to time is replicated. It can be seen from the graph that it requires a start-up time of 5 minutes. This is because the heater requires an initial start-up time for boiling the water for the first cycle. However, in a repeated cycle the initial conditions will reduce, and start-up time can be neglected in such cases implying lesser time for disinfection. After this temperature or start-up point is reached, there is an exponential rise of the output. It can be seen that at 16 min, the output reaches 3 log reductions (99.9%) sterilization with our hybrid WUVH model. Moreover, 4 log reductions (99.99 %), 5 log (99.999 %), and 6 log (99.9999 %) reduction with the WUVH model can be achieved within 23, 35 and ∼ 80 minutes respectively, and Maximum sterilization > 5.5 log reductions can be achieved at 52 minutes. It can also be noticed that to reach 3 log reductions other systems such as UVGISA and WMHSA requires a minimum of 19 minutes and 21 minutes respectively. While the standalone systems attain 3 log 10 reductions (UVGISA in ∼19 minutes) and (WMHSA in ∼ 21 minutes), while for 5 log reduction (UVGISA in >80 minutes) and (WMHSA in >80 minutes). The standalone UVGISA and WMHSA had plateaued ∼ 5 log 10 reduction at 80 minutes, and may not reach 6 log 10 reduction. Table 3 provides the relevant simulation parameter based on the model. This states the efficiency of the hybrid system in terms of quickly achieving the maximum target. Considering the biological aspect, the hybrid system may work even better because the hybrid system can launch a dual attack, where WMH destroys the protein and lipid of any virus, whereas UV destroys the genetic material of the virus. Gayan et al, 2013 showed synergistic 6 log reduction of the bacteria E. coli growth by the use of UV-C light and mild temperature.
• Gayan E
• Manas P
• Alvarez I
• Condon S
Mechanism of the synergistic inactivation of Escherichia coli by UV-C light at mild temperatures.
Moreover, moist heat is considered more effective than dry heat in killing microorganisms.

Pathology for Surgeons in Training, 3Ed. 3rd Edition ed. London: CRC Press

Table 3Simulation parameters
Simulation environmentSpecification/value
Warm heat chamber1
UV chamber1
Moist heat65-70oC
UVC spec17 mW/cm2 at dose ∼1 J/cm2
There is no standard level of antiviral disinfection recommended for N95 respirators. FDA defines high-level disinfection for a short contact time to achieve a 6 log 10 (means 99.9999 %) reduction of an appropriate Mycobacterium species.

Prevention CfDCa. Guideline for disinfection and sterilization in healthcare facilities, 2008. Available at: https://www.cdc.gov/infectioncontrol/pdf/guidelines/disinfection-guidelines-H.pdf. 2019. Accessed June 10, 2020.

Rutala et al have shown that disinfectants demonstrating a 3 log 10 (99.9 %) reduction on carriers are likely to be clinically effective on some surfaces.
• Rutala WA
• Kanamori H
• Gergen MF
• Sickbert-Bennett EE
• Weber DJ
Susceptibility of Candida auris and Candida albicans to 21 germicides used in healthcare facilities.
Considering the infectious nature of SARS-CoV-2, a minimum of >5 log 10 is considered safe. Oral et al used vapor H2O2 for 3 hours to reach 6 log 10 reductions of SARS-CoV-2.

Oral E, Wannomae KK, Connolly RL, et al. Vapour H2O2 sterilization as a decontamination method for the reuse of N95 respirators in the COVID-19 emergency [e-pub ahead of print]. medRxiv. https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.04.11.20062026. Accessed August 28, 2020.

Battelle has launched a vapour hydrogen peroxide system that's FDA approved showed a 6 log 10 reduction in 3 hours with an extra 5 hours off-gassing time. Thus, our hybrid model with the combined effect of WMH and UV together can bring more efficiency and reliability to the decontamination process.
In the second set of experiments, energy, and average exposure/ cm2 emitted from the source is calculated. The energy emitted from the source is shown in Figure 3B. The energy due to UV is calculated using joules law of heating, whereby calculating kilowatt-hour the conversion of equivalent energy is estimated. The energy due to warm heat in a chamber is calculated using Clausius-clapayron relation.
• Koutsoyiannis D
Clausius–Clapeyron equation and saturation vapour pressure: simple theory reconciled with practice.
The calculated pressure with time from the stated relation is used to evaluate the energy of the warm heat chamber. The energy of the WUVH system is due to the combination of both UV and warm heat. It can be seen from Figure 3B that the average energy emitted by WUVH is much more than the other 2 systems. For example, at around 20 min WUVH emits 4.1 kJ whereas UVGISA and WMHSA emit 3.5 kJ and 0.63 kJ respectively. This justifies the efficacy of our system in terms of energy. Moreover, energy has a direct relation in terms of enhancement of average exposure per unit area. This average exposure
• Lindsley WG
• Martin SB
• Thewlis RE
• et al.
Effects of ultraviolet germicidal irradiation (UVGI) on N95 respirator filtration performance and structural integrity.
is an important parameter in determining the actual emissive energy received by the target material during the decontamination process. Figure 4 represents the average exposure and is presented by plotting 2 plots. In the first plot (Fig 4A), average exposure is compared with the time and in the second plot (Fig 4B), a 3D plot is used to accommodate average exposure along with the output (average log reduction) with time. Considering the area of the masks under treatment, the average exposure per unit area is calculated for all the systems WUVH, UVGISA, and WMHSA. It is to be noticed from Figure 4A with time the average exposure is increased for all the processes. However, it is the highest in our proposed WUVH system. For example, in around 20 min, the average exposure/cm2 of WUVH is 13.6 J/cm2 while for UVGISA and WMHSA system, it is 11.5 J/cm2 and 2.05 J/cm2. These sets of results are validated using a 3D plot where it can be noticed that in a given time slot the average exposure is related with the performance of the system in terms of getting appreciable output. For example, in a steady state, within a time slot of 20 min the average exposure of 13.6 J/cm2 for the WUVH system provides an output of 3.5 log reduction. UVGISA and WMHSA system for an average exposure of 11.5 J/cm2 and 2.05 J/cm2 produces 3.1 and 2.7 average log reduction. This suggests that the more energy emitted by the source, the better will be the average exposure, which will result in speeding up the decontamination process. The results show that in the WUVH system, the state of 3 log reduction is reached in much less time with enhanced exposure as compared with other schemes. Moreover, 5 log reduction for WUVH is achieved at an exposure of 25.3 J/cm2 within 36 minutes and greater than 5-log reduction (5.5 log reduction) in 52 minutes with an average exposure of 41.2 J/cm2. Other systems such as UVGISA and WMHSA will reach a maximum of 5 log reductions at 80 minutes with an exposure of 46.6 J/cm2 and 41.6 J/cm2 respectively. This validates the enhances efficacy of our WUVH system as compared to the standalone.
As the masks are subjected to an average exposure as already shown and described through Figure 4, the amount of increased exposure will produce stress (tensile or compressive) in the mask. This may reduce the functionality of the mask with a shrink in its reuse ratio.
• Lin TH
• Chen CC
• Huang SH
• Kuo CW
• Lai CY
• Lin WY
Filter quality of electret masks in filtering 14.6-594 nm aerosol particles: effects of five decontamination methods.
,
• Rottach DR
• Lei Z
Stockpiled N95 filtering facepiece respirator polyisoprene strap performance.
The relation between subjected stress and an appreciable output is described through the third set of experiments. Stress is calculated as the force per unit area. The force inducted on the mask is a property of energy and is calculated as energy per unit meter. Over a timespan, as the exposure is increased, the stress is also bound to be increased. A stress plot and a 3D plot of stress along with output representation are depicted in Figure 5. Although Figure 4 and Figure 5 are structurally alike their functionality in terms of operation and description are different. It can be seen from Figure 5A that considering a time slot of 20 minutes, the stress attained by the mask under WUVH is 0.139 MPa, while for UVGISA and WMHSA, it is 0.117 MPa and 0.021 MPa. These values are suitably placed in a 3D plot (Figure 5B) to justify the role of stress along with output. It can be seen that in 20 minutes time WUVH system reaches 3.5 log reductions with the stress of 0.139 MPa. It is to be noted that this WUVH is a faster system where the standard 3 log reductions are achieved at 16 minutes under comparative less stress of 0.080MPa. Moreover, WUVH system also reaches 5 log reduction at a stress of 0.242 MPa in 36 minutes and greater than 5 log reduction at a stress of 0.422 MPa in about 52 minutes respectively. The other systems will reach the 3 log reductions at a minimum of 4 to 5 minutes later. Moreover, it can also be noticed that WUVH will reach 4 log reductions ensuring 99.99% decontamination in just 23 minutes with the stress of 0.14 MPa. The same output will be achieved by UVGISA at a 30-minute time with the stress of 0.18 MPa while WMSA requires 32 minutes with the stress of 0.040. However, to reach 5 log reduction UVGISA and WMHSA requires a stress of 0.49 MPa and 0.426 MPa at 80 minutes. This suggests that both UVGISA and WMSA are slower systems with more stress required to achieve the maximum. A detailed discussion with other comparison is shown through Table 4 to be discussed later in Section 4.3.
Table 4Exhaustive analyses
ProcessTime required for log reduction (min)Average exposure J/cm2Stress N/m2Reuse
MinMax
WUVH162336526.788.40.0800.31875036
UVGISA193080—-5.646.60.1170.4912830
WMHSA213280—-1.0841.60.0220.4268136

### Statistical analysis

Statistical analysis is done to validate the simulation results (Fig 6). This is done by using box plots with a varying number of runs. Although the WUVH process reaches 99.9% accuracy in terms of 3 log reduction in 16 minutes as a standard to accommodate and compare all the schemes, the simulation is carried on with a varying number of runs up to 20 minutes. It can be seen from the plot that the mean of WUVH is at 3.6 in 20 minutes duration with a maximum and minimum range variation from 3.7 to 3.5. Similarly, UVGISA and WMHSA also have a mean value of 3.1 and 2.8 for 20 minutes. These values are very much consistent with the plots of Figure 3A. Thus, the precision and accuracy of our scheme are justified with this box plot for the same set of parameters.

### Exhaustive analysis

An exhaustive data analysis is presented in Table 4. It is noticed from the table that the WUVH process requires the least time among all other processes to reach a standard reduction required for the decontamination of the masks. Moreover, the average exposure is also more in the case of WUVH than other processes.
• Liao L
• Xiao W
• Zhao M
• et al.
Can N95 respirators be reused after disinfection? How many times?.
This enhanced exposure makes the WUVH system fast by reducing the time to perform decontamination. Stress is a function of exposure but if the target is achieved in lesser time, then stress for the same exposure will also reduce. This is because a targeted mask will be subjected to a lesser duration to achieve the target. To achieve 3 log reductions, it can be noticed that although in WUVH, the exposure is more than UVGISA, the tendency of WUVH to reach the target value in lesser time results in less stress. In this case, WMHSA overrides in terms of stress as exposure at this level is quite less. However, as the process proceeds towards better decontamination levels such as 5 log reductions, due to the inherent characteristics of WUVH, it requires very little time to reach the target. In such a scenario, WUVH has the least stress value compared with other schemes to achieve the target reduction.
The material of the mask is made of Polypropylene having a maximum yield strength of 43 MPa with a tensile strength of 34 MPa, compressive strength 46.5MPa and Fatigue of 24 MPa. The nylon straps have a strength of 45 MPa. Now, considering the factors of filtration resistance and penetration in terms of mask property degradation during the decontamination process, the average strength of the mask can be considered as 15 MPa under the worst-case scenario. The reuse of the mask can be calculated by knowing the stress value to achieve a particular level of decontamination. For example, from Table 4, it is observed that for WUVH, the mask can be reused 50 times if 5 log reduction is to be achieved every time. This value is more than the competing schemes such as UVGISA and WMHSA. Similarly, for >5 log reduction, only mask under WUVH can be reused as other systems will not progress to that level of decontamination. This establishes the success of WUVH as despite having larger exposure, the stress level is always maintained at an appreciable level resulting in a good reuse ratio. Finally, the WUVH setup is designed and fabricated as shown in Figure 7. Figure 8 is showing the sanitization process of medical PPE and domestic material using the WUVH-based instrument.
Moreover, this hybrid system can be used as standalone systems also. The key benefit of this model is that it can be utilized for other domestic and personal sanitization purpose also. This sanitization process is specifically intended for medical masks decontamination and reuse purposes but can also be applied against any other viruses. A model is fabricated and its results are verified by mathematical analysis and simulation. The results show the supremacy of the proposed model in terms of its speed of sanitization and reuse. comprising of moist steam and UV radiation.

## Conclusion and future directions

We have developed a hybrid disinfection model (WUVH) that concomitantly uses UV-C irradiation and heat for effective decontamination. Another feature of this model is that it can be customized to work in 3 modes, such as standalone warm heat, standalone UV or hybrid model. The analysis is supported by creating a mathematical model and by actual fabrication of the model. Simulated results show that the minimum accuracy of 3 log 10 (99.9%) reductions can be achieved within 16 minutes, while >5.5 log 10 reduction is reached in 52 minutes, far quicker than the standalone systems. As per our WUVH model, around 6 log 10 reduction may be reached in 80 minutes but not feasible with the other models. The average exposure is found to be more when compared with other schemes but on the contrary, the stress at the same level of exposure is quite less. The reduced decontamination time increases the reuse ratio of the mask under consideration. The advantage of this process is that the speed of sanitization in achieving efficiency is increased and both the membrane and DNA structure of the virus is damaged. Recent work by Cadnum et al, 2020 suggests that UV-C in a 30-minute cycle reduced contamination but did not meet the disinfection 6 log 10 reductions in 30 minutes. Similar data was also observed with dry heat at 70°C for 30 minutes. The authors suggest that wet heat may be more effective than dry heat, especially when disinfecting an N95 respirator.
• Li D
• Redmond SN
• John AR
• Pearlmutter B
• Donskey C
Effectiveness of ultraviolet-C light and a high-level disinfection cabinet for decontamination of N95 respirators.
Our data is quite similar to that reported by Cadnum et al, 2020.
Our proposed hybrid model that relies on the concomitant use of heat and UV-irradiation can overcome the limitations of the existing single-arm based decontamination system both physically as well as biologically. Various reports suggest that synergistic effect can work better on bacteria.
• Gayan E
• Manas P
• Alvarez I
• Condon S
Mechanism of the synergistic inactivation of Escherichia coli by UV-C light at mild temperatures.
Yang et al, 2019 reported synergistic antimicrobial effect by the use of heat treatment and Lauric Arginate and also with Lauric Arginate and UVA (DOI 10.1128/AEM.01033-19). A dual attack on the viral envelope (heat inactivates viral protein and lipid), while UV causes damage to the genetic material. This aspect can make our proposed hybrid model even more efficacious while tested in vitro. Different brands of respirators and the straps are differentially susceptible to UV and/or high heat. Our model provides options to titrate the different agents accordingly for respective companies. We are in the process of evaluating the in vitro efficacy of our system. To reduce the warm up time and create a better coverage of the disinfecting area we have also integrate UV LED lights with controlled timer system in our model and needs further analysis. Dry heat can also be integrated in place of the moist heat system for certain PPE types. For extreme systems we can also use 30% H2O2 in the WMHSA unit to make a hybrid of UV and wet H2O2 vapor-based sanitation.
Application wise this hybrid model may be used for medical, industrial, domestic and personal sanitization purposes. Moreover, this model is not only restricted to SARS-CoV-2 (coronavirus) but can be used to treat any type of virus/ bacteria. Although the fabricated model is tested as a future extension of this work, the machine will be tested with the real random virus, and analysis to that respect will be made.

## Acknowledgments

M.P. acknowledges Dr. Steven Dubinett and Dr. Brigitte Gomperts from UCLA for providing constant support and mentoring. R.B. acknowledges Dr. Sipra Das Bit of IIEST, Shibpur, Dr. Pijush Pal Roy, Dr. N. N. Pathak, Dr. C. K. Ghosh, and Mrs. Ruma Mitra of Dr. B. C. Roy Engineering College, India, for providing continuous support. R.B. acknowledges Dr. Susanta Dutta for helpful discussion.

## References

• Huang C
• Wang Y
• Li X
• et al.
Clinical features of patients infected with 2019 novel coronavirus in Wuhan, China.
Lancet. 2020; 395: 497-506
• de Wit E
• van Doremalen N
• Falzarano D
• Munster VJ
SARS and MERS: recent insights into emerging coronaviruses.
Nat Rev Microbiol. 2016; 14: 523-534
• Paules CI
• Marston HD
• Fauci AS
Coronavirus infections-more than just the common cold.
JAMA. 2020; 323: 707-708
1. Singh Y, Gupta G, Satija S, Pabreja K, Chellappan DK, Dua K. COVID-19 transmission through host cell directed network of GPCR. Drug Dev Res.2020;81:647-649.

• Wu F
• Zhao S
• Yu B
• et al.
A new coronavirus associated with human respiratory disease in China.
Nature. 2020; 579: 265-269
• Liu J
• Liao X
• Qian S
• et al.
Community transmission of severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2, Shenzhen, China, 2020.
Emerg Infect Dis. 2020; 26: 1320-1323
• Wang Q
• Zhang Y
• Wu L
• et al.
Structural and functional basis of SARS-CoV-2 entry by using human ACE2.
Cell. 2020; 181: 894-904
2. Setti L, Passarini F, Gennaro GD, et al. Airborne transmission route of COVID-19: why 2 meters/6 feet of inter-personal distance could not be enough. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2020;17:2932.

• Ong SWX
• Tan YK
• Chia PY
• et al.
Air, surface environmental, and personal protective equipment contamination by severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) from a symptomatic patient.
JAMA. 2020; 323: 1610-1612
• Lukassen S
• Chua RL
• Trefzer T
• et al.
SARS‐CoV‐2 receptor ACE2 and TMPRSS2 are primarily expressed in bronchial transient secretory cells.
EMBO J. 2020; 39: 1-15
• Lauer SA
• Grantz KH
• Bi Q
• et al.
The incubation period of coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) from publicly reported confirmed cases: estimation and application.
Ann Intern Med. 2020; 172: 577-582
• Azap A
• Erdinc FS
Medical mask or N95 respirator: when and how to use?.
Turk J Med Sci. 2020; 50: 633-637
• Wang X
• Pan Z
• Cheng Z
Association between 2019-nCoV transmission and N95 respirator use.
J Hosp Infect. 2020; 105: 104-105
• Liao L
• Xiao W
• Zhao M
• et al.
Can N95 respirators be reused after disinfection? How many times?.
ACS Nano. 2020; 14: 6348-6356
• Kim JM
• Chung YS
• Jo HJ
• et al.
Identification of coronavirus isolated from a patient in Korea with COVID-19.
Osong Public Health Res Perspect. 2020; 11: 3-7
• Matsuyama S
• Nao N
• Shirato K
• et al.
Enhanced isolation of SARS-CoV-2 by TMPRSS2-expressing cells.
Proceed Natl Acad Sci. 2020; 117: 7001-7003
• Cascella M
• Rajnik M
• Cuomo A
• Dulebohn SC
• Di Napoli R
Features, Evaluation and Treatment Coronavirus (COVID-19).
StatPearls, Treasure Island (FL)2020
• Balazy A
• Toivola M
• Sivasubramani SK
• Reponen T
• Grinshpun SA
Do N95 respirators provide 95% protection level against airborne viruses, and how adequate are surgical masks?.
Am J Infect Control. 2006; 34: 51-57
• Nogee D
• Tomassoni AJ.
Covid-19 and the N95 respirator shortage: closing the gap.
Infect Control Hosp Epidemiol. 2020; 4: 958
• Van Doremalen N
• Bushmaker T
• Morris DH
• et al.
Aerosol and surface stability of SARS-CoV-2 as compared with SARS-CoV-1.
N Engl J Med. 2020; 382: 1564-1567
• Lam T-N
• Wu C-H
• Huang S-H
• et al.
Multi-scale microstructure investigation for a PM2.5 air-filter efficiency study of non-woven polypropylene.
Quantum Beam Science. 2019; 3: 20
• Heimbuch BK
• Kinney K
• Lumley AE
• Harnish DA
• Bergman M
• Wander JD
Cleaning of filtering facepiece respirators contaminated with mucin and Staphylococcus aureus.
Am J Infect Control. 2014; 42: 265-270
3. Kenney P, Chan BK, Kortright K, et al., Hydrogen peroxide vapour sterilization for N95 respirators for reuse [e-pub ahead of print]. medrxiv. https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.03.24.20041087. Accessed August 28, 2020.

• Heimbuch BK
• Wallace WH
• Kinney K
• et al.
A pandemic influenza preparedness study: use of energetic methods to decontaminate filtering facepiece respirators contaminated with H1N1 aerosols and droplets.
Am J Infect Control. 2011; 39: e1-e9
• Viscusi DJ
• Bergman MS
• Novak DA
• et al.
Impact of three biological decontamination methods on filtering facepiece respirator fit, odor, comfort, and donning ease.
J Occup Environ Hyg. 2011; 8: 426-436
• de Man P
• van Straten B
• van den Dobbelsteen J
• van der Eijk A
• Horeman T
• Koeleman H
Sterilization of disposable face masks by means of standardized dry and steam sterilization processes; an alternative in the fight against mask shortages due to COVID-19.
J Hosp Infect. 2020; 105: 356-357
• Lindsley WG
• Martin Jr., SB
• Thewlis RE
• et al.
Effects of ultraviolet germicidal irradiation (UVGI) on N95 respirator filtration performance and structural integrity.
J Occup Environ Hyg. 2015; 12: 509-517
4. WA Rutala, DJ Weber. Disinfection and sterilization: an overview Am J Infect Control. 2013;41:S2–S5.

• Rabenau HF
• Cinatl J
• Morgenstern B
• Bauer G
• Preiser W
• Doerr HW
Stability and inactivation of SARS coronavirus.
Med Microbiol Immunol. 2005; 194: 1-6
• Darnell ME
• Subbarao K
• Feinstone SM
• Taylor DR
Inactivation of the coronavirus that induces severe acute respiratory syndrome, SARS-CoV.
J Virol Methods. 2004; 121: 85-91
• Ariza-Mateos A
• Prieto-Vega S
• Diaz-Toledano R
• et al.
RNA self-cleavage activated by ultraviolet light-induced oxidation.
Nucleic Acids Res. 2012; 40: 1748-1766
• Watkins NJ
• Nowzari C
• Pappas GJ
Robust economic model predictive control of continuous-time epidemic processes.
IEEE Transact Automatic Control. 2020; 65: 1116-1131
• Lee JH
Model predictive control: review of the three decades of development.
Int J Control Autom Syst. 2011; 9: 415-424
• Gayan E
• Manas P
• Alvarez I
• Condon S
Mechanism of the synergistic inactivation of Escherichia coli by UV-C light at mild temperatures.
Appl Environ Microbiol. 2013; 79: 4465-4473
5. Pathology for Surgeons in Training, 3Ed. 3rd Edition ed. London: CRC Press

6. Prevention CfDCa. Guideline for disinfection and sterilization in healthcare facilities, 2008. Available at: https://www.cdc.gov/infectioncontrol/pdf/guidelines/disinfection-guidelines-H.pdf. 2019. Accessed June 10, 2020.

• Rutala WA
• Kanamori H
• Gergen MF
• Sickbert-Bennett EE
• Weber DJ
Susceptibility of Candida auris and Candida albicans to 21 germicides used in healthcare facilities.
Infect Control Hosp Epidemiol. 2019; 40: 380-382
7. Oral E, Wannomae KK, Connolly RL, et al. Vapour H2O2 sterilization as a decontamination method for the reuse of N95 respirators in the COVID-19 emergency [e-pub ahead of print]. medRxiv. https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.04.11.20062026. Accessed August 28, 2020.

• Koutsoyiannis D
Clausius–Clapeyron equation and saturation vapour pressure: simple theory reconciled with practice.
Eur J Phys. 2012; 33: 295-305
• Lindsley WG
• Martin SB
• Thewlis RE
• et al.
Effects of ultraviolet germicidal irradiation (UVGI) on N95 respirator filtration performance and structural integrity.
J Occup Environ Hyg. 2015; 12: 509-517
• Lin TH
• Chen CC
• Huang SH
• Kuo CW
• Lai CY
• Lin WY
Filter quality of electret masks in filtering 14.6-594 nm aerosol particles: effects of five decontamination methods.
PLoS One. 2017; 12e0186217
• Rottach DR
• Lei Z
Stockpiled N95 filtering facepiece respirator polyisoprene strap performance.
J Int Soc Respir Prot. 2017; 34: 69-80